Category Archives: Free speech

Clark drops Holocaust scholar Finkelstein

Boston Globe: Clark drops Holocaust scholar
Schedule conflict, controversy cited

Clark University canceled a campus talk scheduled for later this month by controversial Holocaust scholar Norman Finkelstein, saying his presence “would invite controversy and not dialogue or understanding,” and would conflict with a similar event scheduled around the same time.

The Clark University Students for Palestinian Rights, a student-run group on the Worcester campus, had arranged for Finkelstein to speak on April 21, said Tom MacMillan, the group’s president. School administrators, however, contend the topic and the timing conflict with a similar university-sponsored event.

Caption gaffe: Apostates, instead of Apostles ‘worst possible mistake’

The Salt Lake Tribune: Caption gaffe: Apostates, instead of Apostles ‘worst possible mistake’
Newspaper » BYU reprints issues of The Daily Universe due to front page typo.

Provo » The phone call Rich Evans got Monday morning wasn’t good news.

It was an employee at Brigham Young University’s The Daily Universe , where Evans is the editorial manager. There was a typo on the front page.

“It was the worst possible mistake,” Evans recalled.

The error? A caption on a photo from this weekend’s LDS General Conference stated that “Members of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostates and other general authorities raise their hands in a sustaining vote Saturday morning. …”

The newspaper staff retrieved as many of the 18,500 copies of the paper as possible and reprinted them with the correction. And it issued an apology to the apostles. The staff also explained how it happened: an error in spell-checking.

BC won’t air Ayers lecture by satellite

Boston Globe: BC won’t air Ayers lecture by satellite
Decision frustrates student organizers

Boston College, citing pressure from Brighton residents and Boston police officers, refused to allow former radical William Ayers to deliver a student-sponsored lecture via satellite yesterday, frustrating student organizers who accused the college of sacrificing academic ideals to assuage public anger.

Ayers video conference canceled, students to hold lecture on academic freedom in its place

BC Heights: Ayers video conference canceled, students to hold lecture on academic freedom in its place

The Boston College administration has decided not to allow a video conference with Bill Ayers, who was scheduled to speak in person at the University tonight, to take place on campus. The event was originally organized by the BC chapter of Americans for Informed Democracy (AID); it was canceled on Friday out of what a statement from the Division of Student Affairs cited as “concern for the safety and well being of our students and respect for the local community where the alleged actions of the Weather Underground continue to reverberate today.”

Ayers BC speech moved off campus

Boston Globe: Ayers to speak at BC via satellite link

In an example of what a student organizer referred to as “academic freedom for the 21st century,” William Ayers, a professor at the University of Illinois at Chicago and former member of the Weather Underground Organization, will address Boston College students – but not on campus. After administrators on Friday cancelled Ayers’ appearance, scheduled for this evening, students scrambled to find an off-campus venue, said Melissa Roberts, vice president of the College Democrats of Boston College. They found a large enough location at the last minute, Roberts said, so Ayers will speak via satellite from Chicago. The talk, which is open only to BC students, faculty, and staff, will be held at 6 p.m. in Devlin Hall.

Cops dump MIT student paper

Boston Globe: MIT suspends 2 police officers
Newspaper copies with arrest story were dumped

Two MIT police officers, apparently unhappy with the student newspaper’s coverage of a fellow officer’s recent arrest for drug trafficking, did the only thing they could think of to block the bad news: They trashed it.

Ayers Banned in Boston

Inside Higher Ed: Banned in Boston

The norm for protests over a William Ayers appearance on campus these days is for conservative critics to say that the University of Illinois at Chicago professor shouldn’t be given a forum to speak because of the past violence of the Weather Underground, of which he was once a leader.

At Boston College, the debate has taken a new twist — with the college calling off a talk by Ayers planned for tonight and citing a police killing that has never been definitively linked to the Weather Underground and that Ayers and others insist his group had nothing to do with. Nonetheless, that 1970 police killing is still associated by many in Boston with the Weather Underground and remains a political flashpoint — as became clear on Friday.

Michael Graham, a local talk radio host, started calling on Boston College to revoke the invitation to Ayers, and he encouraged alumni, donors and others to call the college to demand that it deny Ayers a forum. Graham repeatedly linked Ayers and the Weather Underground to the 1970 killing of Walter Schroeder, the police officer, who was responding to a bank robbery by a group of radical students. Schroeder left a wife and nine children. His killing is periodically back in the news, and last received extensive coverage in 1993, when Katherine Ann Power — one of those involved in the incident, who had evaded capture and lived under another name — turned herself in.

Universities Are Betraying Their Central Mission


This poster for Israeli Apartheid Week was taken down by staff at Carleton University & the University of Ottawa.

CAUT Bulletin: Universities Are Betraying Their Central Mission

Over the past few weeks, CAUT has become aware of a number of disturbing cases in which university administrations have limited or suppressed debate on controversial issues. Whether it is banning posters or noisy demonstrations, we believe such heavy-handed actions constitute a clear threat to the purpose of post-secondary education.

Not surprisingly, the failures involve bitterly contentious issues. One is Middle East politics. Last month Carleton University and the University of Ottawa banned a student organization poster for Israeli Apartheid Week because the universities felt it too provocative. The poster, by noted political cartoonist Carlos Latuff, shows a stylized Israeli warplane firing a missile at a child holding a teddy bear and standing on ground emblazoned with the word “Gaza.” York University has gone even farther, invoking a noise policy to justify handing club suspensions and fines to student organizations that held counter-protests for and against Israeli

Anti-abortion activists defy university

The Calgary Sun: Anti-abortion activists defy university

Potential new trespassing charges didn’t scare away anti-abortion crusaders who are back at the University of Calgary campus with their controversial display.

York wants more civil Israeli-Palestinian debate

Globe and Mail: York wants more civil Israeli-Palestinian debate

TORONTO — A month after rancorous and polarizing on-campus fights about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, York University will announce today its plans to steer the debate back toward civility.

Nursing Student Sues After U. of Louisville Expels Her for Online Posts About Patients

The Chronicle News Blog: Nursing Student Sues After U. of Louisville Expels Her for Online Posts About Patients

A former nursing student at the University of Louisville sued the institution in federal court yesterday, alleging that it had violated her free-speech and due-process rights by expelling her for her posts on MySpace, where she wrote about her patients, gun rights, and abortion, among other issues.

Explosive Problem for the University of Louisville – Nursing Student Expelled for MySpace Blog

PageOneKentucky.com: Explosive Problem for the University of Louisville – Nursing Student Expelled for MySpace Blog

On Thursday, March 5th we learned that a nursing student at the University of Louisville was expelled because of a post on her MySpace account.

And it’s official. A law suit was filed today alleging the University has violated rights to free speech.

Georgia Southern U. Rescinds Speaking Invitation to William Ayers

The Chronicle News Blog: Georgia Southern U. Rescinds Speaking Invitation to William Ayers

Georgia Southern University has rescinded a speaking invitation to William Ayers, an education professor at the University of Illinois at Chicago who remains controversial for his involvement in the 1960s in the radical group the Weather Underground.

Ontario: Queen’s silences campus language-police program

Globe and Mail: Queen’s silences campus language-police program

Queen’s University has pulled the plug on a controversial program aimed at correcting students who are using language that might be deemed offensive.

The experimental program, which employed six students to step in when they heard undergraduates using racial slurs or making homophobic comments, set off a fierce debate over freedom of expression on campus. News of the language police spread through the school’s extensive alumni network and made national headlines.

Free Speech and Ohio Trustees

Inside Higher Ed: Free Speech and Ohio Trustees

Amid criticism from local and national quarters — criticism that Ohio University officials said was premature — a committee of the institution’s Board of Trustees on Thursday substantially revised a draft “statement of expectations” for the board’s own members that had been viewed as potentially gagging dissent and shielding university officials from scrutiny. The draft policy, which the board was reportedly supposed to take up at Thursday’s meeting, called for individual trustees to direct “concerns about university operations” to the university’s president and said board members should “publicly support” decisions once consensus on an issue is reached. The policy came under attack from the American Council of Trustees and Alumni (which said the guidelines would render the trustees “nothing more than potted plants”) and from The Post, Ohio’s student newspaper, whose editorial said: “The board wants to put on a public mask that hides the sometimes-ugly realities of running a university. It expects students and taxpayers to believe that this board and the administrators it hires are the arbiters of good decisions, and it refuses to answer to those who question that authority.” At Thursday’s meeting, the policy’s drafters insisted that they had never intended to interfere with members’ right to speak their minds, and the board’s governance committee went “virtually word by word” through the policy, said Sallly Linder, a university spokeswoman. “Everybody agreed to change any language in it that seemed an attempt in any way to result in the quashing of free speech,” Linder said, noting that the board would consider the revised policy, when it is redrafted, at its April meeting.

Australian sentenced for insulting Thai monarchy

AP: Australian sentenced for insulting Thai monarchy

BANGKOK, Thailand (AP) — An Australian writer was sentenced Monday to three years in prison for insulting Thailand’s royal family in his novel, a rare conviction of a foreigner amid a crackdown on people and Web sites deemed critical of the monarchy.

Group Tells Public-College Presidents They May Be Personally Liable for Speech Codes

The Chronicle: Group Tells Public-College Presidents They May Be Personally Liable for Speech Codes

A group that advocates free speech on campuses has sent the top officials of 266 public colleges certified letters warning them that they might be sued as individuals if their institutions do not lift certain speech restrictions.

The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, based in Philadelphia, mailed the letters to college presidents and chancellors in mid-December in an effort to pressure their institutions to alter their speech policies voluntarily. The letters cite several court rulings that the group regards as prohibiting one or more speech policies in place at the colleges, and they argue that the administrators, having been apprised of such developments, will have difficulty claiming legal immunity from liability for their actions.

Thai university professor accused of defaming Thai monarchy

Channelnewsasia.com: University professor accused of defaming Thai monarchy

Thai university professor accused of defaming Thai monarchy

BANGKOK: A university professor in Thailand is accusing Thai authorities of mounting a witch hunt against him. Giles Ji Ungpakorn has been accused of lese majeste or defaming the Thai monarchy.

It’s Not Just Yelling ‘Fire’ in a Theater That Can Get You in Trouble

VOA: It’s Not Just Yelling ‘Fire’ in a Theater That Can Get You in Trouble

One day in 1992, a University of Pennsylvania student had trouble studying in his Philadelphia dormitory because other students were talking loudly outside. He threw open the window and shouted, “Shut up, you stupid water buffalo!”

Free-Speech Group Says Most Colleges Violate the First Amendment

The Chronicle News Blog: Free-Speech Group Says Most Colleges Violate the First Amendment

Nearly three-quarters of colleges and universities maintain unconstitutional speech codes, according to a report released today by the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education. The group, known as FIRE, gave 270 of 364 institutions a “red light” for having “at least one policy that both clearly and substantially restricts freedom of speech.” In last year’s report, FIRE gave 259 of 346 colleges and universities that designation: 74.9 percent, compared with 74.2 percent this year.