Educational Testing Service to pay millions for errors in teacher tests

The Educational Testing Service has agreed to pay $11.1 million to settle a class action suit over errors in its primary teacher-licensing test, The New York Times reported. The funds will be used to compensate teachers who lost jobs or some wages because of their incorrect test scores. The Times reported that 27,000 people who took the test in 2003-4 received scores that were incorrectly low, and that more than 4,000 of these people were incorrectly told that they had failed.

As with student testing in schools, states have increased testing for current and prospective teacher, despite the fact that there is no evidence to support the claim that standardized tests predict who will be a good teacher.

There is also a long history of cultural bias on teacher licensure tests, which are typically taken upon exit from teacher education programs. A recent National Research Council report on teacher tests concludes that raising cut-off scores on these tests will reduce racial diversity in the teaching profession without improving quality. The differences in average scores among racial/ethnic groups on teacher licensure tests are similar to the differences found among these groups on college admission tests, showing substantial disparities between the passing rates of white and minority test takers.

Most importantly, the NRC found that these tests (including the PRAXIS, which is an ETS product and is the most widely used teacher test in the US) do not predict who will become effective teachers. The NRC concluded that by their design and as currently used tests like the PRAXIS fall short in their use as accountability tools, as levers for improving teacher preparation, and encourage erroneous conclusions about the quality of teacher preparation. Nevertheless, over 40 states rely on standardized tests for teacher licensure.

Current efforts to improve learning and teacher quality rest on a misguided use of standardized tests. Rather than improving learning or increasing teacher quality, the latest research indicates that an emphasis on testing results actually lowers student academic performance, increases dropout rates, and serves as a barrier to diversifying the teaching profession with improving teacher quality.

For more information on teacher testing check out FairTest.org.

The Pirate Bay: Winning the file-sharing wars?

The Pirate Bay: Here to Stay?

From wired.com
By Ann Harrison
02:00 AM Mar, 13, 2006 EST

Last month, the Motion Picture Association of America announced one of its boldest sorties yet against online piracy: a barrage of seven federal lawsuits against some of the highest-profile BitTorrent sites, Usenet hosts and peer-to-peer services. Among the targets: isoHunt, TorrentSpy and eDonkey.

But, as always, one prominent site is missing from the movie industry’s announcement (.pdf), and it happens to be the simplest and best-known source of traded movies — along with pirated video games, music, software, audio books, television broadcasts and nearly any other form of media imaginable. The site is called The Pirate Bay, and it’s operated by a crew of intrepid Swedes who revel in tormenting the content industries.

“All of us who run the TPB are against the copyright laws and want them to change,” said “Brokep,” a Pirate Bay operator. “We see it as our duty to spread culture and media. Technology is just a means to doing that.”

A quick look at The Pirate Bay’s lineup suggests which side is winning the piracy wars. Among the site’s most popular downloads are recent Oscar nominees and winners like Closer and Brokeback Mountain, Steven Spielberg’s Munich, the latest Harry Potter film and even stinkers like Underworld: Evolution and The Pink Panther. Downloading doesn’t require users to register or install spyware — if one has a BitTorrent client installed, anything listed is just a click away.

To international observers, The Pirate Bay’s defiant immunity from copyright lawyers is somewhat baffling. But in Sweden, the site is more than just an electronic speak-easy: It’s the flagship of a national file-sharing movement that’s generating an intense national debate, and has even spawned a pro-piracy political party making a credible bid for seats in the Swedish parliament.

Founded in 2003 by a loosely knit crew of file-sharing advocates called Piratbyrån, or Pirate Bureau, The Pirate Bay began life as a Swedish-language site occupying a second tier among popular torrent trackers. Then the MPAA’s groundbreaking 2004 crackdown on torrent hubs changed everything. As famous sites like SuprNova and LokiTorrent went under, their users crowded onto the surviving hubs like pelicans on a reef. When the storm passed, The Pirate Bay remained.

According to “Anakata,” one of the site’s operators, subsequent MPAA lawsuits have continued to drive more users to The Pirate Bay, which today boasts 1 million unique visitors a day. The Pirate Bay’s legal adviser, law student Mikael Viborg, said the site receives 1,000 to 2,000 HTTP requests per second on each of its four servers.

That’s bad news for the content industries, which have fired off letter after menacing letter to the site, only to see their threats posted on The Pirate Bay, together with mocking replies. Viborg said that no one has successfully indicted The Pirate Bay or sued its operators in Swedish courts. Attorneys for DreamWorks and Warner Bros., two companies among those that have issued take-down demands to the site, did not return calls for comment.

Viborg credits The Pirate Bay’s seeming immunity to the basic structure of the BitTorrent protocol. The site’s Stockholm-based servers provide only torrent files, which by themselves contain no copyright data — merely pointers to sources of the content. That makes The Pirate Bay’s activities perfectly legal under Swedish statutory and case law, Viborg claims. “Until the law is changed so that it is clear that the trackers are illegal, or until the Swedish Supreme Court rules that current Swedish copyright law actually outlaws trackers, we’ll continue our activities. Relentlessly,” wrote Viborg in an e-mail.

MPAA spokeswoman Kori Bernards insists The Pirate Bay violates copyright laws around the world. “Copyright laws are being enforced and upheld in countries all over the world and when you facilitate the illegal file swapping of millions of people around the world, you are subject to those laws,” said Bernards. “The torrent and torrent tracker is something that points people to various files that make up a copyright that is protected under the law.”

That legal claim is untested in the United States, according to Fred von Lohmann, senior staff attorney for the Electronic Frontier Foundation.

In Sweden, the legality of the trackers is a topic of considered debate.

For more on The Pirate Bay see: File-sharing thrives under the radar

Battle of the blogs: The Nation launches “StudentNation” / The National Review launches “Phi Beta Cons”

The Nation has announced the launch of StudentNation—a new student-based web-page.

You’ll find details on The Nation‘s student programs and projects, activist resources, info on upcoming Nation events, links to student articles and blog posts, a question of the week, a collection of featured student websites, select Nation articles and, eventually, a progressive calendar and a student-produced photo blog. Be sure to check out the articles from the special issue on “The New Face of the Campus Left.”

Or, if the “liberal/left” Nation is not for you, check out thenew blog Phi Beta Cons, which is billed as “the right take on higher ed”—that’s right as in ultra right wing.

The blog, is sponsored by William F. Buckley, Jr.’s The National Review. The blog is described as “dedicated to keeping an eye on the politics of campus life.”

So far drawn postings from Stephen Balch, of the National Association of Scholars, on the Lawrence Summers resignation; David Gelernter on Yale’s admission of an ex-Taliban spokesman as a student; SUNY Trustee Candace de Russy on the “Jihad on campus”; and Anne D. Neal, of the American Council of Trustees and Alumni, on what she describes as “the vast divide” between “academic elites & mainstream America.”

A curriculum on slavery in New York State

20060312_032115_slavery031206.jpgThe Associated Press has distributed a story about the New York Slavery curriculum, which Alan Singer, a social studies prof at Hofstra University, developed with Mary Carter (Hofstra U), April Frances (Lawrence Road MS, Uniondale), Kerry Creegan (Massapequa HS, Massapequa) and with support from numerous social studies education colleagues.

The curriculum guide is a 2005 National Council of the Social Studies “Social Studies Program of Excellence” award winner.

The complete document-based curriculum guide, which was prepared for the “Gateway to the City” Teaching American History Grant Project is available on the New York State Council for the Social Studies web site.

The photo shows Singer speaking about New York’s role in the American slavery system, at Oyster Bay High School in Oyster Bay, N.Y.

March Badness: A bracket you won’t see anywhere else

Well, it’s we’re in the thick of March Madness (or if you’re a Vancouver Canucks fan “March Badness,” but that’s another story), and the folks at Inside Higher Ed have come up with a rather unique take on “The Big Dance,” asking “What if the tidal wave of frenzied ethnusiasm” for college hoops was directed at applauding the graduation rates of basketball players, rather than their tourney prowess?

The Inside Higher Ed brackets show how 65 teams in the NCAA tournament advance from the first round through the “Sweet Sixteen,” “Elite Eight,” and “Final Four,” down to a National Championship for hoops player graduation rates. Teams advance based on their NCAA Graduation Success Rate, as compiled by the Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sport, at the University of Central Florida, which released its annual report on the academic performance of college sports teams on Sunday.

In this alternative universe the mighty Bucknell Bison prevail.

The institute found that 64 percent of the teams in the tournament graduated at least 50 percent of their basketball players according to the Graduation Success Rate, the NCAA’s newly conceived accounting measure, and 36 percent of the teams graduated at least 70 percent of their players. Only 25 percent of the teams graduated fewer than 40 percent of their players. (The Graduation Success Rate differs from the widely used federal rate by excluding from the calculation athletes who leave the institution in good academic standing before graduating, and including those who transfer into the institution and graduate. As a result, the rates tend to be about 10 percent higher than the federal rate on average.)

The institute highlighted racial disparity as the most glaring problem. Sixty-six percent of the teams graduated at least 70 percent of their white players, while only 33 percent did the same with black players. Twenty-five tournament teams have at least a 30 percentage point gap between the graduation rates of white and black basketball players.

The Final Four in the NCAA Graduation Success Rate Tournament includes:

Bucknell U Bison
Villanova U Wildcats
U of North Carolina at Wilmington Seahawks
U of Illinois Fighting Illini

Dowload your brackets here.

Are public schools hotbeds of democracy?

Well, they ought to be …

In an op-ed for the Seattle Post-Intelligencer Walter Parker (an education professor at U of W) argues that schools should seize the opportunty to become hotbeds of democracy by (1) increasing the variety and frequency of interaction among students who are culturally, linguistically and racially different from one another; (2) orchestrate interactions among students so that they are involved in decision-making about common problems (deliberation); and (3) expect, teach, and model competent, inclusive deliberation in the classroom.

Sound advice. And, the first step in making these things happen is to consider the obstacles that keep these practices from being more widespread in public schools … perhaps the most significant obstacle is the narrowing of the curriculum that results from the pursuit of increased test scores.

Video of UBC Roundtable on the British Columbia Teachers’ Strike

Vic_Rally_1.jpgFollowing last fall’s BC teachers’ strike a number of departments and programs at UBC, along with the New Proposals Publishing Society and <a href=”http://www.cust.educ.ubc.ca/workplace/”Workplace: A Journal for Academic Labor sponsored a public roundtable discussion on the significance of the strike and the struggle for education in the public interest in British Columbia.

Streaming video of the presentations at the roundtable are now available via Charles Menzie’s In Support of Public Education blog or you can click on any of the presenters names below to access the video:

Stephen Petrina (Department of Curriculum Studies, UBC)
Jinny Sims (President British Columbia Teachers’ Federation)
Catherine Evans (BC Society for Public Education)
Paul Orlowski (Teacher, Kitsilano Secondary School, Vancouver)
Charles Menzies (Department of Anthropology & Sociology, UBC)
Kevin Millsip (former Vancouver School Board Trustee)
E. Wayne Ross (Department of Curriculum Studies, UBC)

Rouge Forum Update (March 6, 2006)

RF4.jpgFrom Rich Gibson in San Diego:

The Rouge Forum No Blood For Oil is updated.

Of special interest this week:

*To top the Oscars, a new online archive of movies whose copyrights have expired, including the classic Marxist and almost altogether banned Salt of the Earth is here, download free!

*Baltimore students took the lead in direct action, opposing counterfeit claims to school reform.

*The AFL-CIO, gutted by a massive loss of member, and a deep internal split, promised to spend $40 million of its members dues income on electoral campaigns. It is unclear how the AFL-CIO plans to outbribe the truly rich, or how the union bosses plan to be sure the politicians they bribe, stay bribed.

*The split in the AFL-CIO represents a falling out among opportunists. Clearly, the NEA has lined up with old guardsman, John Sweeney, in forming a partnership to inveigle dues from NEA members, and a few luncheons for misleaders of both organizations. The AFL-CIO’s organizing principle remains the unity of politicians, corporate leaders, and union leaders, in the “national interest,” that is, against the interest of rank and file members, and against the interest of workers in the rest of the world.
Andy Stern was Sweeney’s protege, and is president of the Service Employees International Union. He betrayed Sweeney, led a splinter group involving nearly half of the members of the AFL-CIO, including some of the most mobbed-up unions in the US, including the Teamsters, the UFCW, and UNITE-HERE. With SEIU, each union can take credit for organizing large numbers of low-wage workers, and bargaining the minimum wage for them, minus union dues.
Stern’s work is described in a recent article, “His goal was to consolidate AFL-CIO’s 58 affiliated unions, no longer blame corporations on all of its troubles, and to re-establish the labor union as a partner instead of an adversary to corporations and multinationals.”

*A new book by Robert Fitch, while narrow in scope, limiting its critique to union corruption (with some amusing side glances to those “public intellectuals who, from comfortable positions, refuse to recognize the dead-end of US unionism), is worth the candle: Solidarity for Sale.

*Watch for the next issue of Substance News for a description of this week’s AFL-CIO executive committee meeting in San Diego.

*March 18 marks year three of US capital’s invasion of Iraq, for oil and social control of the vital mid-east region, seeking to stave off moves from Russia, China, Europe, and Japan. The failure of the US military adventure, already lost, is breathtaking. Here are past, and prescient, articles from the Rouge Forum News.

*We have joined with hundreds of other grassroots groups to endorse the many demonstrations that will take place throughout the world on March 18. Join us!

U.S. Supreme Court attacks First Amendment rights

In a 21-page opinion written by Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., the U. S. Supreme court rejected arguments that colleges have a First Amendment right to exclude recruiters whose hiring practices conflict with their own antidiscrimination policies.

The court ruled unanimously this morning that the federal government can withhold federal funds from colleges that bar or restrict military recruiting on their campuses, upholding a decade-old law (known as the Solomon Amendment) requiring colleges to provide equal access to military recruiters.

The Supreme Court’s decision in the case, Rumsfeld v. Forum for Academic and Institutional Rights, No. 04-1152, overturned a 2004 ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, which found that the military had failed to show that its recruiting needs justified the intrusion on law schools’ constitutional rights. In its ruling, the appeals court cited a 2000 decision by the U.S. Supreme Court, Boy Scouts of America v. Dale, that allowed the Boy Scouts to exclude a gay assistant scoutmaster.

Even the so-called “liberals” on the Court were willing to toss out free speech and nondiscrimination arguments in deference to the military.