US Supreme Court to rule on file swapping

Justices to rule on file swapping this week

At issue is a series of lower court decisions that have enraged studio and label executives by saying that file-swapping companies such as Grokster are not legally liable for the widespread piracy that happens on their networks.

At the core of the file-swapping dispute is an interpretation of the 20-year-old decision that made Sony’s Betamax legal to sell in the United States. Much of the subsequent consumer electronics industry has been built with that decision in mind, and now companies are worried that it’s open for review.

In 1982, testifying in front of Congress before the Supreme Court had ruled, MPAA President Jack Valenti said, “I say to you that the VCR is to the American film producer and the American public as the Boston strangler is to the woman home alone.” Hmmm…sounds like BS to me…

That’s bullshit!

IMHO the best book of the summer is Harry G. Frankfurt’s On Bullshit.

This book is essential reading if you watch television “news,” work in a university, or just happen to be alive in the 21st Century.

Frankfurt attempts to build a theory of bullshit that distinguishes it from “humbug” and “lying”. He argues that bullshitters misrepresent themselves to their audience not as liars do, that is, by deliberately making false claims about what is true. In fact, bullshit need not be untrue at all.

Rather, bullshitters seek to convey a certain impression of themselves without being concerned about whether anything at all is true. They quietly change the rules governing their end of the conversation so that claims about truth and falsity are irrelevant.

In the end, Frankfurt muddies the water as to whether George W. Bush is merely a liar or bullshitter–but for Frankfurt a bullshitter is a more insidious threat to the truth than a liar is.

Either way it’s obvious that the majority of Americans are in need of reading this book.

Are bullshiitters more reprehensible than liars? A short video interview with Harry G. Frankfurt.

Criminalizing childhood?

In response to the increased use of “antisocial behaviorial orders” against children, The Council of Europe’s human rights commissioner, Alvaro Gil-Robles, said this month that Britain’s policy on antisocial behaviour was criminalising children. He said no juvenile under 16 should be at risk of imprisonment for breaching an antisocial behaviour order. Asbos should be “restricted to serious cases”.

Civil liberties groups have raised concerns that local authorities are using the powers of the orders as a short cut to imposing criminal punishments. An Asbo [antisocial behavior order] is granted as a civil power, but a breach of the order is treated as an offence punishable by up to five years in prison, or a young offenders’ institution.

The wide terms of the legislation mean that a magistrate can grant an Asbo by being satisfied only on a balance of probabilities that the accused’s behaviour is “likely to cause alarm, harassment or distress”.

Groups such as the British Institute for Brain Injured Children, a charity working with young people with behavioural difficulties, say that the Government’s targeting of “families from hell” could lead to the demonising of children with Asperger’s syndrome or other problems.

In the first year of the Asbo, 1999, only a few dozen applications were made to the courts. Since then, Labour has introduced laws to strengthen their use while giving councils and police more money to fund applications. In many cases, an Asbo against a child is now accompanied by a naming and shaming order.

The Children’s Society has said that it is “very concerned about the Government policy to “name and shame” children who receive Asbos. Liz Lovell, a policy adviser at the society, said: “The policy is not only counter-productive, it puts children and young people at risk. We are also opposed to the proposed extension of this policy in the Serious Organised Crime and Police Bill. ‘

Full story available here

NYS alternative schools under attack

In The New York Times, Michael Winerip reports on the latest efforts of New York State Education Department to destroy alternative schools via the imposition of mandatory graduation tests.

Students in New York must pass five exams to graduate from high school. In the mid-1990s, former state education commissioner Thomas Sobel granted 28 alternative schools (serving 16,000 students) an exemption from most state tests that permitted more innovative curriculum and teaching.

Current NYS Education Commissioner, Rick Mills believes that all students, without exception, should take every test. Mills has turned New York’s public schools into one of the most test-driven systems in the US.

Mills has been battling the alternative schools–now organized as the New York Performance Standards Consortium–for years and may have the upper hand as the exemptions handed out by Sobel are set to expired.

Consortium schools now have the backing of the chairmen of the education committees in both the State Assembly and the Senate Education, so the stage is set for what might be test of Mills’ draconian rule as the biggest test-pusher this side of George W. Bush.

For more on the NY Performance Standards Consortium see: resisting the tyranny of tests.

Why the Downing Street memo matters

TomDipatch.com presents a through overview of the importance of the Downing Street memo and the gutless US media’s failure to cover the story.

Imagine that the Pentagon Papers or the Watergate scandal had broken out all over the press — no, not in the New York Times or the Washington Post, but in newspapers in Australia or Canada. And that, facing their own terrible record of reportage, of years of being cowed by the Nixon administration, major American papers had decided that this was not a story worthy of being covered. Imagine that, initially, they dismissed the revelatory documents and information that came out of the heart of administration policy-making; then almost willfully misread them, insisting that evidence of Pentagon planning for escalation in Vietnam or of Nixon administration planning to destroy its opponents was at best ambiguous or even nonexistent; finally, when they found that the documents wouldn’t go away, they acknowledged them more formally with a tired ho-hum, a knowing nod on editorial pages or in news stories. Actually, they claimed, these documents didn’t add up to much! because they had run stories just like this back then themselves. Yawn.

This issue of TomDispatch also has an exchnage between reporter John Walcott and Mark Danner, author of the The New York Review of Books article “The Secret Way to War.”

Two top guns shoot blanks

The New York Times‘ Frank Rich has done more to expose fake news than just about anyone. In his column today, he draws a parallel between the war in Iraq and H.G. Wells’ War of the Worlds…and between W and Tom Cruise (star of Speilberg’s cinematic adaptation of Wells’ classic story).

The shelf life of the fakery that sold the war has also expired. On June 7, a Washington Post/ABC News poll found for the first time that a majority of Americans believe the war in Iraq has not made the United States safer. A week later Gallup found that a clear majority (59 percent) wants to withdraw some or all American troops. Most Americans tell pollsters the war isn’t “worth it,” and the top reasons they cite, said USA Today, include “fraudulent claims and no weapons of mass destruction found” and “the belief that Iraq posed no threat to the United States.” The administration can keep boasting of the Iraqi military’s progress in taking over for Americans and keep maintaining that, as Dick Cheney put it, the insurgency is in its “last throes.” But when even the conservative Republican congressman who pushed the House cafeteria to rename French fries “freedom fries” (Walter B. Jones of North Carolina) argues for withdrawal, it’s fruitless. Once a story line becomes incredible, it’s hard to get the audience to fall for it again.

The US Senate’s meaningless apology on lynching

Last week the US Senate issued a formal apology to lynching victims (over 5,000 documented cases) and their descendents. The first time Congress has apologized to African Americans for any reason.

(Eight senators refused to support the apology: Larmar Alexander (TN), Thad Cochran (MS), John Cornyn (TX), Mike Enzi (WY), Craig Thomas (WY), Judd Gregg (NH), John Sununu (NH), and the Senate’s biggest racist of all, Trent Lott (MS).)

The Black Commentator‘s cover story this week ask why some Black folks are happy to hear an apology from people who don’t mean it?

“There are nearly a million African Americans in prison — one out of eight inmates on the planet — a gulag of monstrous proportions, clearly designed to perpetuate the social relations that began with slavery. We demand an end to those relations, not an insincere, risk-free “apology” that sets not one prisoner free.”

In the same issue of The Black Commentator, Margaret Kennedy muses on why racist Dixiecrats (who filibustered every effort to pass anti-lynching legislation in the Senate) turned Republicans, like Senatory George Allen (VA), are delivering an apology for lynching.

Teaching (and learning from) the US experience in Vietnam

ZNet Commentary
Lessons From Vietnam: Wars Kill Empires As Well As People
June 06, 2005
By Saul Landau

In 2005, the United States has become Communist Vietnam’s single-largest trading partner. Vietnam’s products permeate U.S. stores. But the “Vietnam War trauma” remains central to U.S. politics. Note how the Vietnam service record of presidential candidates became a contentious issue in the 2004 elections. People don’t overcome traumas unless they understand them.

Since public education provides citizens with minimal context, we rely on mass media to reach into its collective attic and drag out “Fall of Saigon” stories. However, when the commercial press pushes the anniversary method of history teaching, the public tends to divorce rather than engage with its past connections.
Personal anecdotes overwhelm analysis. Relatives of dead soldiers weep at Washington’s Vietnam Wall; others relive battles and deaths of comrades. Few media presentations offer the past as a way to learn for the future.

As the U.S. occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan continue down their bloody paths, we should study the lessons of The Vietnam War. Vietnamese refer to that period between the early 1960s and April 1975 as “The American Phase.” They suffered periods of foreign domination by Chinese, Japanese and French occupiers who, unlike the Americans, learned the painful lesson of trying to subdue and occupy that land.

U.S. leaders adamantly refuse to learn that some people, like Koreans, Vietnamese and Iraqis, for examples, do not submit to force and brutality. How to teach that simple lesson? Teachers will have shared the experience of trying to educate students who have not ingested their own history. Instead of inculcating historical context from first grade on, U.S. students learn a kind of patriotic mythology disguised with words like “unbiased” – as if along with critiques of U.S. behavior in Vietnam – or Iraq – one had to present the good side of torture, mass murder and the napalming of villages.

A Voice of America reporter sympathized with U.S. historians who “have struggled for years to find a fair and balanced way to teach students about the Vietnam War – and the atrocities committed there by U.S. soldiers” (Maura Jane Farrelly, April 28, 2005 ).

“Fair and balanced” sound discordant in the era of Fox News and CNN. Teachers should show students news clips of the inglorious U.S. retreat from Saigon in April 1975. Military helicopters took off from the Embassy with desperate Vietnamese clients clinging to them and falling to the ground.

The high school texts don’t tell that story. Steve Jackson, an Indiana University of Pennsylvania Political Science professor, found that students in his Introduction to American Politics course “have little if any knowledge about the Vietnam War and its lessons. He finds that appalling, especially in light of the U.S.’s current involvement in Iraq.” (Michael A. Fuoco, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette April 28, 2005).

Gore Vidal calls this syndrome “The United States of Amnesia.” As memorials abound and the media teemed with veterans recalling fallen comrades and anecdotes of combat, many school boards want history taught as lessons of right and wrong in which our leaders might make mistakes, but don’t do evil.

As a result, my college students don’t know that the U.S. military dropped more bombs on Southeast Asia than they did in World War Two. General Curtis LeMay, wanted to bomb Vietnam “back to the Stone Age.” How Christian!

Despite overwhelming military superiority, the U.S. lost in Vietnam. When American forces departed in 1975, the U.S. puppet army in Saigon “had over three times as much artillery, twice as many tanks and armored cars, 1,400 aircraft and a virtual monopoly of the air and “a two-to-one superiority of combat troops” (Kolko, Anatomy of War: Vietnam, the US and the Modern Historical Experience.” See Counterpunch April 30, 2005).

Seven years earlier, the North Vietnamese lost a major battle and won the war. In late January 1968, the armies of the North and National Liberation Front of the South staged an armed uprising during Tet, the Vietnamese holiday. General Giap and the other Hanoi leaders had decided that the levels of casualties exacted by massive U.S. artillery shelling and bombing had become intolerable. Giap’s quick military victory plan called for coordinated attacks on targets near the South Vietnam border to lure U.S. troops away from the cities, where dramatic assaults took place by Viet Cong (the pro Communist forces in the South and by regular North Vietnamese troops who had infiltrated South Vietnam’s urban areas). Giap predicted that such bold and large scale initiatives would inspire citizens to revolt against the puppet South Vietnamese government. The fall of this U.S.-backed regime would remove the last pretext for occupation and the Americans would withdraw.

The puppet government, however, didn’t fall. U.S. forces took about 1,100 casualties and many more wounded, but then retaliated, inflicting heavy casualties on Giap’s troops – some 35,000 killed and 60,000 wounded. But Giap’s plan did lead to an unanticipated victory in the propaganda war. One TV news clips showed Viet Cong fighting their way inside the heavily-guarded U.S. Embassy in Saigon, thus dramatizing the gap between official statements of optimism about the enemy’s weakness and the real battlefield facts.

The Tet Offensive thus revealed the absurdity of President Lyndon Johnson’s boasts of how much “the enemy” had been permanently weakened. The fact that the offensive took place after repeated official assurances of impending victory – seeing light at the end of the tunnel, according to Defense Secretary McNamara – so undermined the war propagandists’ efforts that public opinion swayed convincingly against the war. Despite their immense losses, the North Vietnamese won the propaganda war.

Seven years after Tet, the TV public saw images of U.S. embassy officials burning documents and U.S. money to prevent the rapidly advancing Communists from getting them. These pictures and the commentaries that accompanied them induced disgust and doubt in the wisdom of U.S. leaders. Three years later, if doubts persisted about the duplicity of U.S. officials, Daniel Ellsberg, a former national security official, released a massive archive of documents that the New York Times printed. The thousands of documents in the Pentagon Papers confirmed that the government had lied and covered up important facts about the origins of the war. They also showed that the United States had made little “progress” in winning the “hearts and minds” of Vietnam’s people. The Pentagon Papers also revealed that Lyndon Johnson had lied repeatedly and that neither he nor any other official had devised a plan to end the war and leave. The credibility gap between government and people became unbridgeable.

Most Americans don’t remember or know why the United States intervened and then got deeper into Vietnam. Its leaders had not learned from Korea, where another tough Asia foe fought U.S. troops to a bloody standstill. Bush has repeated the murderous scenario in Iraq. In each war, the U.S. killing machine slaughtered many more natives than Americans. In Vietnam, Lyndon Johnson confessed to his National Security Adviser McGeorge Bundy that he didn’t “think it’s worth fighting for.” But he continued to send hundreds of thousands of troops to kill and die – and ultimately lose.

On May 1, the paper of record featured a particularly foolish account. Stephen J. Morris of Johns Hopkins University’s School of Advanced International Studies blamed anti-war lobbying for convincing Congress to cut funding, thus assuring the Communist victory in Vietnam. How many of the NY Times readers will recall the instant collapse of the militarily superior, U.S.-trained South Vietnamese army when they had to fight? How many will remember that the United States invented South Vietnam in 1955 as a way to avert a national electoral victory by President Ho Chi Minh? Or that rampant corruption characterized all the U.S.-picked regimes. How many will know that the U.S. chose Catholics to rule a predominantly Buddhist population? Morris’ sour grapes scenario belies the facts: South Vietnam in early 1975 showed all the signs of decomposition.

The Times does not print historian Gabriel Kolko’s vital lessons. “Successive administrations in Washington have no capacity whatsoever to learn from past errors. Total defeat in Vietnam 30 years ago should have been a warning to the U.S.: Wars are too complicated for any nation, even the most powerful, to undertake without grave risk. They are not simply military exercises in which equipment and firepower is decisive, but political, ideological, and economic challenges also. The events of South Vietnam 30 years ago should have proven that.” (Counterpunch, April 30, 2005)

In Iraq, Bush repeats Lyndon Johnson’s sinful stupidity of wasting a surplus on military and security madness. Congress’ new budget froze domestic spending, but not military and “security” funding. Bush’s advisers should read him Pat Buchanan’s lines from A Republic, Not an Empire: ”
all the empires had disappeared. How did they perish? By war – all of them.”

Landau’s new book is THE BUSINESS OF AMERICA: HOW CONSUMERS HAVE REPLACED CITIZENS AND HOW WE CAN REVERSE THE TREND. He directs Digital Media at Cal Poly Pomona University’s College of Letters, Arts and Social Sciences and is a fellow of the Institute for Policy Studies.

Elvis rules!

First, you should know I like Elvis and not just in a postmodern ironic way, though I understand that take on the King.

The British music rag NME recently carried an item on the Top 100 Most Successful Acts of All Time, based on the total number of weeks an act has spent on the UK singles and album charts and … Elvis checks in at No. 1 ahead of Cliff Richard, The Beatles, Queen and Madonna. (The Rollings Stones are unbelieveably No. 16.)

Now, if NME’s list has you hankering for some Elvis, for your listening pleasure I recommend The Memphis Record, the best single disc collection of his “comeback” material (including “Suspicious Minds,” “Kentucky Rain,” “True Love Travels on a Gravel Road,” “Stranger in My Own Home Town,” “Long Black Limousine,” “Only the Strong Survive,” “In the Ghetto,” and many other superb songs…really).

If you’re still unconvinced try reading the best rock biography ever written: Peter Guralnick’s 2 volume bio of Elvis (Last Train to Memphis and Careless Love).

If you continue to reject the grand narrative of the King of Rock n Roll, then perhaps you can enjoy him as an ironic, cultural icon … Try reading Greil Marcus’s biography of Elvis after he left the building, Dead Elvis, where he quite successfully argues that Elvis has been more important dead than he ever was while alive…

Thank you very much…

“Ten most harmful books of the 19th & 20th centuries”

The “conservative” weekly Human Events asked a panel of 15 conservative scholars and public policy leaders to help them compile a list of the Ten Most Harmful Books of the 19th & 20th Centuries.

Each panelist nominated a number of titles and then voted on a ballot including all books nominated. A title received a score of 10 points for being listed No. 1 by one of our panelists, 9 points for being listed No. 2, etc. “Appropriately,” according to the editors, The Communist Manifesto, by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, earned the highest aggregate score and the No. 1 listing. Marx was the only author to have 2 entries, with Das Kapital at No. 6.

John Dewey’s Democracy and Education checked in at No. 5. Here’s the summary of Dewey’s most important work provided by the editors of Human Events

Summary: John Dewey, who lived from 1859 until 1952, was a “progressive” philosopher and leading advocate for secular humanism in American life, who taught at the University of Chicago and at Columbia. He signed the Humanist Manifesto and rejected traditional religion and moral absolutes. In Democracy and Education, in pompous and opaque prose, he disparaged schooling that focused on traditional character development and endowing children with hard knowledge, and encouraged the teaching of thinking “skills” instead. His views had great influence on the direction of American education–particularly in public schools–and helped nurture the Clinton generation.”

The balance of the list includes Hitler’s Mein Kampf (No. 2), Quotations from Chairman Mao (No. 3), and The Kinsey Report (No. 4).

Rounding out the top ten are: Betty Friedan’s The Feminine Mystique, Comte’s The Course of Positive Philosophy, Nietzsche’s Beyond Good and Evil, Keynes’ The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money.

The link above will take you to the full list, including “summaries” and a run down of the panel.

In an effort to preserve free enterprise against the assualt of Top Ten (and honorable mention) books by Marx, Engels, Mao, and Lenin, Human Events has convienently provided links to Amazon.com for each title for your consuming pleasure (or perhaps to facilitate local book burnings).

(Thanks to DG for the tip on this list, I’ll have to remember to send him a gift subscription to Human Events for his next birthday.)